Hello dear
Welcome To Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern
Welcome to Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern, a hidden gem located in Columbus, Ohio. Known for its laid-back atmosphere, this eatery offers a menu that tantalizes with delightful dishes like their signature beef stroganoff and gochujang wings. Patrons rave about the quality of food served at reasonable prices, making it a perfect destination for a family dinner or a night out with friends. The attentive service shines through as servers like Devin and Allison ensure a memorable experience. With a pop culture-inspired menu, Rusty Bucket stands out as a solid choice for an enjoyable meal that feels both familiar and unique.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern
Welcome to Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern, a charming eatery located at 4109 N High St, Columbus, OH 43214. This establishment offers an inviting atmosphere coupled with a diverse menu, making it a favored spot for both locals and visitors. Whether you're in the mood for comforting classics or explorative dishes, Rusty Bucket hits the mark.
As you step inside, you’re greeted by a laid-back vibe that encourages you to unwind. The rustic decor and pop culture references sprinkled throughout the menu create a unique dining experience. Diners rave about the attentive service, showcasing the restaurant's commitment to guest satisfaction. For instance, many have highlighted servers like Devin, whose enthusiasm and attentiveness enhance the overall experience.
One of the standout dishes here is the beloved Ruben Sandwich, praised for its perfection on the first try by satisfied patrons. Meanwhile, others cannot get enough of the beef stroganoff and gochujang wings, which have emerged as crowd favorites, pulling diners back for more. The generous portion sizes paired with reasonable prices make it easy to indulge without breaking the bank.
Moreover, Rusty Bucket's atmosphere is perfect for gatherings. Whether it's a casual dinner or a celebratory occasion, the restaurant accommodates large parties effortlessly, ensuring everyone feels special. One exemplary guest experience was recounted by Neil James, who praised the remarkable service during a private event, proving that here, every celebration is treated with care.
The testimonials from customers like Norm Zurawski and Kimberly Adams encapsulate the essence of Rusty Bucket: a reliable gem where comfort food meets quality service, all in a friendly setting. It’s this predictability—coupled with a touch of excitement from a diverse menu—that invites you to return time and again.
In a city where dining options are abundant, Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern stands out as a destination for satisfying meals that won’t disappoint. So gather your friends or family, and soak in the welcoming ambiance while enjoying some truly delicious food!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ I hesitate to say this is a 5-start restaurant, but what I got was very good, as good as I would have hoped, and the price was totally reasonable. Someone else mentioned that this is a solid & predictable place and I have to say that's fair. In 2024, you can easily pay 100 for a meal that just isn't that good. We paid far less than that and the meal was good. Very safe, predictable, and good place to eat dinner at a very reasonable price. ”
“ We're not from around the area and struggled to find a good bite in Columbus. This place was packed, but got us a table in 20 minutes. Service was a bit slow due to people calling out, but it's a nice enough place with good drinks that it was fine to be slowish. The beef stroganoff and gochujang wings were the highlights for us. ”
“ First time we went there everything was delicious I order a Ruben Sandwich it was perfect , the service is outstanding Devin the server was amazing and helpful! ”
“ The atmosphere was laid back, the food was delicious, good portion sizes and decent pricing, our server was sweet and friendly, and I love the pop culture references in the menu. 10/10 definitely check this place out! ”
“ We had a party of 18 in a private room, Allison took care of us for hours. She kept our glasses full and the apps and dinners on our tables. When a single individual is committed to that level of service (and the food is so tasty!) she deserves to be recognized as an example for your consistently great food and atmosphere. Thank you for hosting our celebration. Highly recommend. (P.s. DOUBLE Allison’s pay; you’re not going to find better!) ”
“ Top quality service and food. Never been disappointed by any menu item but always find it hard not to order the buffalo chicken sandwich! Great draft beer selection with some nice happy hour deals. The place is always busy so keep that in mind ”
“ Rusty Bucket is always one of the easiest dinner decisions in the neighborhood. It’s not that expensive, the vibe is relaxed, and the food never disappoints. Our usual go-to’s are the Buffalo Chicken Sandwich, Fish & Chips, Double Nickel Salad, and French Onion soup. Recently, I had the Chicken Parmesan and it was so good I decided to try a new entree each visit. As luck would have it, tonight was Sunday and the special was the Kentucky Hot Brown! Admittedly, I’ve only had one before this...at the Brown Hotel in Louisville, KY, so the bar was kinda high. This version, although served different, was actually more enjoyable than the OG! I can’t wait to try it again! I’m sharing a photo of that, and the Double Nickel salad (I subbed Ranch for the house dressing this time, although either option is pretty unbeatable, I was simply craving something closer to a Wedge Salad this evening.) Cheers! ”
“ Great place for large gatherings. Consistently good food and great service. ”